Are Collagen Supplements Worth Taking?

Do you know if collagen supplements are worth taking? Here is all you need to know about them before you go buying anything displayed at your local pharmacy or fitness shop.

The world of supplement is intriguing, promising, and full of information – sometimes not always accurate. Collagen is gaining prominence not just for its health benefits but also for its specific roles in recovery and physical fitness. Unlike traditional protein supplements that primarily aim to enhance muscle mass and recovery, collagen offers a unique set of advantages for connective tissues, which are crucial for overall mobility and joint health.

The information for this article is based on a conversation shared on YouTube between Peter Attia and Luc van Loon.

Luc van Loon is a distinguished professor of Exercise Physiology and Nutrition at Maastricht University in the Netherlands. Renowned for his research in the field of skeletal muscle metabolism, van Loon has significantly contributed to our understanding of muscle protein synthesis, exercise, and the role of nutrition in muscle recovery and performance.

Peter Attia is a prominent figure in longevity, health optimization, and medicine. Through his medical practice and involvement in research initiatives, Attia focuses on extending lifespan and improving quality of life. A thought leader in health and wellness, he communicates complex medical concepts effectively, emphasizing the significance of nutrition, exercise, and lifestyle choices in optimizing health and longevity.

This article will focus on collagen will explore its importance and functionality within the body’s structural framework, particularly in muscles and connective tissues.

What You Need to Know About Collagen

Collagen is a major component of connective tissues throughout the body, including skin, bones, tendons, ligaments, and cartilage. It is instrumental in providing structure and strength to these tissues. In muscles, collagen serves as a crucial element, albeit in smaller quantities compared to structural proteins like myosin and actin. It plays a vital role in connecting muscle fibres to tendons, a key process that enables the transfer of force during muscle contraction.

The amino acids, primarily glycine and proline, found in collagen are essential for building and repairing connective tissues. This is particularly beneficial for joint health. As noted in their conversation, “collagen is a very nice source of glycine and proline… about 50% of your collagen is glycine and proline.” This high concentration makes collagen supplements a targeted choice for individuals looking to support these specific aspects of their physiological health.

Source: Gute Macedo on Pexels

Despite the evident benefits collagen offers to connective tissues, its effectiveness in directly boosting muscle protein synthesis, especially post-exercise, is limited. Luc van Loon points out that “the ingestion of dairy protein or protein does not seem to increase muscle connective protein synthesis rates,” indicating that while traditional proteins like whey stimulate muscle growth, collagen’s impact might be subtler and more specific to connective tissue health. Moreover, studies mentioned by him show that “we do not see a greater increase in connective tissue protein synthesis rates in muscle” when collagen is used, suggesting its benefits are not as immediate or pronounced in muscle development as they are in connective tissue maintenance.

8 Best Supplements to Build Muscle

Are Collagen Supplements Worth Taking?

The worth of collagen supplements can be viewed through the lens of its specific benefits to connective tissues rather than its effectiveness in muscle protein synthesis. Collagen is highlighted for its potential benefits to skin, bone, ligaments, and other connective tissues due to its high glycine and proline content, making it beneficial for individuals seeking to enhance joint and skin health.

However, van Loon also indicates that collagen might not be as effective in stimulating muscle protein synthesis as other protein types like whey, particularly in the context of post-exercise recovery. Van Loon suggests that while collagen doesn’t significantly boost muscle connective tissue synthesis following exercise, it shouldn’t be completely dismissed as it provides valuable amino acids that are essential for connective tissue health.

Source: Scott Webb on Unsplash

Neither Luc van Loon nor Peter Attia specify an exact amount of collagen that should be taken daily. Generally, the dosage of collagen supplements can vary depending on the specific product and the goals of the individual. Typical collagen supplements might recommend dosages ranging from 5 to 15 grams per day, but it’s essential to follow the specific guidelines provided by the product manufacturer or a healthcare professional.

5 Fat Loss Supplements That Actually Work

While collagen may not directly enhance muscle protein synthesis like whey or casein, its value lies in supporting the integrity and functionality of connective tissues. This makes collagen an essential supplement for those focused on long-term joint health and the prevention of connective tissue-related injuries. For athletes or anyone engaged in regular physical activity, incorporating collagen could provide the foundational support necessary for sustained physical performance and recovery.

In essence, while collagen should not be relied upon for building muscle mass, its role in promoting the health and resilience of connective tissues is undeniable, making it a worthy addition to a holistic approach to fitness and health maintenance.

Watch the video for more information about collagen, if they are worth taking and any other questions you might have revolving the subject.

Read Also: 3 Supplements You Should Take to Improve Your Fitness